Belong7 Jan 2026Simon Druery

A neutral mindset: How to balance fear and opportunity in times of change

When the outside world is chaos (like always!) - sometimes you want to bury your head in the sand or get obsessed with that new shiny object. It seems change is the only constant, which is why it’s more important than ever that as a leader, you stay calm, open and neutral. A neutral mindset helps leaders and teams respond with thoughtfulness instead of reacting with panic or hype. It recognises fear without being ruled by it and sees opportunity without overpromising outcomes. Only when you are feeling centred can you see both sides fully. And that’s important when you are managing both a team, communications and your brand.

Every January brings hope and anxiety

January often feels like a fresh start. Leaders and teams plan, reflect and set intentions for the year ahead. Yet alongside this energy lies a deeper question: What will this year bring?

That question carries weight. With ongoing workplace disruption from artificial intelligence, organisational restructures, and ambiguity in roles, people are increasingly pulled toward two emotional extremes. One moment there is fear that technology and change will displace jobs. The next there is hype about opportunity but perhaps without clear direction on how to realise it.

In this context, a neutral mindset is essential. And don’t be fooled into thinking that being neutral is a passive state. What it really is, is a stabilising leadership skill that enables thoughtful reaction rather than triggered responses. It acknowledges fear without being defined by it and recognises opportunity without creating false hope.

Why neutrality matters more now than ever

Change is constant and accelerating. From emerging technologies to shifting market conditions, teams experience multiple significant shifts each year. 

For example, in Australia, concerns about the impact of artificial intelligence are widespread. I’ve seen it in our clients’ businesses and also my own. And yes - I’m guilty of downloading dozens of AI prompting guides for fear of missing out on the latest hack! Alas - 90% of the ones I’ve downloaded I’ve never read. Instead I’ve found over time that simply taking action and using the tools is the best teacher. That said, not everyone has the capacity, access or desire to embrace change. And that’s a problem.  

  • A recent study found that 60 per cent of Australians fear losing their jobs to AI, the highest reported globally in that research, with an estimated 670,000 roles potentially automatable by 2030. AMI 
  • National research shows 64 percent of Australians fear losing control to AI, with many feeling less optimistic about their long‑term future. KPMG 
  • While many Australian workers use AI tools at work, only around 35 per cent have received formal training, leaving almost two‑thirds without structured support from leadership. EY 

These data points reinforce a nuanced reality. People both use and benefit from AI while feeling uncertain about its effects. Some embrace the promise of new skills and efficiencies, others are cautious or anxious about potential disruption. In many workplaces, leadership direction and psychological safety lag behind the pace of change.

This emotional volatility matters because your reactions as a leader ripple across teams, networks and even social media algorithms. When leaders swing between panic and hype, it reinforces extremes in those around them.

Neutrality doesn’t ignore the risks or the opportunities. It stabilises both your people, organisation and brand so all both can be seen clearly and addressed constructively.

Leadership sets the tone for how change is experienced

The influence leaders hold during change is enormous. Research shows leadership accounts for almost three‑quarters of success or failure in major organisational change initiatives. PwC

Surely the most important predictor of how people handle uncertainty is psychological safety. Workers who feel they can speak up, experiment and learn without penalty are significantly more motivated and capable of navigating change successfully. Yet many do not feel safe to use new tools or ask questions about them. EY

Neutral leadership is not apathy. It is a set of behaviours that creates space for thoughtful engagement, balanced assessment and informed decision-making.

What neutral leadership looks like in practice

Here are four leadership behaviours that build and embody neutrality:

1. Acknowledge fear without amplifying it
 Fear is natural in times of ambiguity. Naming it openly validates people’s experience without allowing anxiety to dominate the conversation. For example:

“Many of us are unsure about how AI might change our roles. That uncertainty can feel unsettling. Here is what we know, and here is how we are exploring what comes next.”

This approach treats fear as information to work with instead of something to be fixed or denied.

2. Frame opportunity with realism
 Opportunity exists but is not automatic or guaranteed. Leaders who overstate positives risk creating disillusionment later. Instead, frame the possibilities with conditions and clear next steps:

“We see potential to improve workflows through AI tools. Over the coming quarter we will test a few ideas, measure results and adjust based on what we learn.”

This helps teams engage with purpose without chasing expectations that outpace evidence.

3. Slow down the narrative to speed up outcomes
 Ambiguity creates pressure to fill silence with certainty. A neutral mindset encourages thoughtful pacing. It gives people time to reflect, ask questions and absorb new information before decisions are finalised.

4. Build psychological safety through neutral responses
 Neutral leadership signals steadiness rather than volatility. Research indicates that when leaders demonstrate openness, adaptability and support, psychological safety improves. PwC

When people feel safe to speak up without fear of retribution, organisations gain early insight into problems and a broader range of perspectives on solutions.

A simple framework for practising neutrality

Use the following approach to strengthen neutral leadership:

  • Name the fear
     State the concerns people may have without exaggeration. Invite conversation.
  • Name the opportunity
     Share what is possible, with context on conditions and unknowns.
  • Hold both without collapsing
    Do not lean entirely toward panic or hype. Stay anchored in observable facts and empathy.
  • Model calm responses
     How leaders react to ‘stress signals’ matters. A calm presence signals that uncertainty is manageable.

This framework is not a one‑off fix. It is a leadership orientation that deepens with practice. Over time it builds trust, resilience and collective capability.

Neutral leadership strengthens organisational core

The evidence is clear. Leaders who navigate uncertainty without reactionary responses help teams thrive. Psychological safety, motivation and readiness to change are not abstract ideals. They are measurable factors that influence performance, innovation and organisational health.

Neutral leadership signals confidence: confidence in the organisation’s direction, confidence in the people who make it work and confidence in the capacity to learn through change.

As this year unfolds with new challenges and disruptive technologies, senior leaders and people leaders have an opportunity to anchor their teams in a mindset that holds fear and opportunity in balance. That mindset creates space for thoughtful action, steadies teams and strengthens belonging not because change is easy, but because it is navigated with clarity and care.

Neutral leadership does not remove the emotional experience of change. It holds every part of it with steady attention. When leaders do this, teams feel more stable with a stronger sense of belonging. In turn, they are better equipped to adapt, innovate and achieve sustainable momentum.

References

Article by Simon Druery

Simon Druery is Director and Brand Strategist at Belong Creative. What gets him jumping out of bed each day is helping business owners and marketers craft brands that people want to belong to. When he’s not working you can find him travelling Australia in the family caravan and enjoying a tawny port by the fire. 

Like more help?

Brand-Strategy
Brand Strategy

Boost acquisition, loyalty and advocacy to drive business performance.

LEARN MORE
Research
Explore insights

Our blogs are bursting with ideas and added value.

LEARN MORE
Get-in-Touch
Get in touch

Need a trusted strategic partner? We’d love to help you create belonging for your brand.

LET'S CONNECT